小练习|AI写作检测:两题检验你的理解
- 2026-11-16 22:27:54
【做题前说明】
下面两道题分别考信息源区分和例证作用。建议先回到原文定位,再比较选项之间的程度和对象差异。
【原文速查】
P6|In an email to NPR, the client confirmed that she had screened McGraw's work for AI. But she said the results were not the determining factor in choosing to hire a different writer, instead citing experience and fit. McGraw says she was paid for her writing samples, but believes the detector results cost her the opportunity to write the full book proposal.
P11|While AI detectors have gotten more sophisticated in recent years, the companies behind the detectors acknowledge that the tools aren't foolproof. Researchers have found that different AI detection tools can reach dramatically different conclusions about the same piece of writing.
P15|Previously published writing can pose an additional problem, says Chris Callison-Burch, a professor of computer and information science at the University of Pennsylvania.
P16|"Many AI detectors work by asking a large language model how predictable a passage is," Callison-Burch said. "The catch is that the language models also tend to find text from their training data unusually predictable."
P17|That could explain what science blogger Janelle Shane encountered in late 2022 when she tested excerpts from her 2019 book about how AI works, You Look Like a Thing and I Love You. One detector reported a 98.7% confidence that a passage was machine-generated.
P18|"This is a clear, glaring, blinking-light false positive," Shane said. "I had written this text myself."
【阅读模拟题】
Q1. What does McGraw believe about the client’s decision?
A. It cost her the book proposal opportunity.
B. It had no effect on the client’s hiring.
C. The client preferred a more experienced writer.
D. She was not paid for her writing samples.
Q2. The author mentions Janelle Shane’s book to show that ______.
A. detectors can misread previously published writing
B. AI detectors are always wrong about writers
C. writers should avoid publishing books on AI
D. her book was largely machine-generated
做完后重点复盘:Q1 要区分「客户怎么说」和「McGraw 怎么认为」;Q2 要判断例子服务的是哪一个观点。